The debate over the MLB greatest starting pitcher brings together legends who shaped the game with dominance and consistency. Fans often compare career stats, big-game performances, and longevity to decide the best starting pitcher. This poll highlights the stars widely regarded as the MLB greatest pitchers of all time, giving you the chance to vote for the pitcher who truly deserves the top spot.
These 20 MLB players were pulled from the article "The 50 Greatest Starting Pitchers in MLB History" See the article
Sports Fan Products
Auto Amazon Links: No products found. Blocked by captcha.
The MLB Greatest Starting Pitcher Poll
The debate over the MLB greatest starting pitcher highlights pitchers who shaped baseball with dominance, longevity, and unmatched skill. Fans often compare peak performance, career totals, and postseason impact to determine the best starting pitcher in league history. Many of the legends featured in this poll are also widely considered among the MLB greatest pitchers of all time, making the discussion even more competitive.
Nolan Ryan is frequently mentioned in conversations about the MLB greatest starting pitcher due to his unmatched strikeout record and seven no-hitters. His longevity and powerful fastball defined an era and cemented his place among the MLB greatest pitchers of all time.
Bob Gibson is another top contender. His fierce presence, dominant World Series outings, and award-winning seasons make him a strong candidate for fans voting on the best starting pitcher in MLB history. His peak years showed unmatched control and intensity on the mound.
Sandy Koufax remains a legendary name. His peak stretch, often considered one of the best in baseball history, featured multiple Cy Young Awards and postseason brilliance. His career may have been short, but his impact keeps him firmly in the conversation for the MLB greatest starting pitcher.
Greg Maddux brought a different kind of excellence. Known for precision and intelligence, he controlled games without relying on overpowering velocity. His consistency and four straight Cy Young Awards make him a natural pick when comparing the MLB greatest pitchers of all time.
Tom Seaver’s command, durability, and elite strikeout ability made him one of the most respected pitchers ever. His complete skill set keeps him at the top of any discussion about the best starting pitcher across generations.
Randy Johnson adds power to the list. His intimidating size, high strikeout totals, and dominant postseason performances place him among the MLB greatest pitchers of all time. Many fans still view him as one of the most overpowering pitchers ever.
Each legend brings a unique case, making this poll an exciting way to determine the MLB greatest starting pitcher based on fan opinion. Your vote helps decide which baseball icon truly deserves the top ranking.
