MLB Greatest First Basemen

STH Clash of Logos MLB - Banner




MLB Logo

The Greatest MLB First Baseman

Determining the greatest MLB first basemen of all time is a subjective task, as it involves weighing various factors such as individual statistics, impact on the game, and personal preferences. Let's take a closer look at the players you mentioned and their contributions to the position:

Albert Pujols: Albert Pujols is undoubtedly one of MLB's most accomplished first basemen. With his combination of power, consistency, and all-around offensive prowess, Pujols has amassed impressive career numbers, including over 600 home runs and a career batting average above .300. He has won multiple MVP awards and played a significant role in leading the St. Louis Cardinals to two World Series championships. Pujols' longevity and sustained excellence make him a strong contender for the title of the greatest first baseman.

Willie McCovey: Willie McCovey is a legendary figure in the history of the first base position. Known for his prodigious power and ability to hit towering home runs, McCovey was a feared hitter during his time with the San Francisco Giants. He won the National League MVP award in 1969 and finished his career with over 500 home runs. McCovey's impact on the game and his influence as one of the premier power hitters of his era certainly make him a strong candidate for consideration.

Steve Garvey: Steve Garvey had an outstanding career as a first baseman, primarily with the Los Angeles Dodgers. Known for his consistency and clutch performances, Garvey was a pivotal contributor to the Dodgers' success in the 1970s, helping them win multiple pennants and a World Series championship. He was an excellent contact hitter and won the National League MVP award in 1974. While Garvey's numbers may not match up with some of the other candidates, his impact on the game and his ability to perform in big moments cannot be overlooked.

Jeff Bagwell: Jeff Bagwell, a stalwart for the Houston Astros, is widely regarded as one of his era's most complete first basemen. Bagwell was a consistent offensive force known for his blend of power, speed, and defensive skills. He won the National League MVP award in 1994 and finished his career with over 400 home runs and a high on-base percentage. Bagwell's well-rounded contributions to the game and his ability to impact both offensively and defensively make him a strong contender for the title.

Orlando Cepeda: Orlando Cepeda, nicknamed "Baby Bull," was a dominant first baseman during his career. With his powerful swing and ability to drive in runs, Cepeda was a consistent offensive threat. He won the National League MVP award in 1967 and finished his career with over 350 home runs. While Cepeda's career was not as long as some of the other candidates, his impact on the game and his offensive prowess make him a player worth considering.

Don Mattingly: Don Mattingly, known as "Donnie Baseball," was a beloved figure during his time with the New York Yankees. Mattingly was known for his smooth swing, excellent defensive skills, and leadership qualities. He won the American League MVP award in 1985 and had several outstanding seasons. Mattingly's career statistics may not match up with some of the other candidates, but his impact on the game and his popularity among fans make him a player with a strong case for consideration.

Determining the greatest MLB first baseman of all time is subjective and open to interpretation. Each player has left an indelible mark on the game and has a compelling case for being labeled "The Greatest MLB First Basemen." It ultimately comes down to personal preferences and the weight one places on different aspects of their career.

MLB Products

Greatest Player Poll 350

Who is the greatest first baseman in the MLB of All-time?

These 20 MLB first basemen were pulled from the article "25 Greatest First Basemen in Baseball History" See the article