The USFL greatest player debate brings back memories of football’s most exciting moments. Fans continue to argue over who deserves the title of USFL best player, as the league saw incredible talent and unforgettable performances. From powerful quarterbacks to unstoppable running backs, this poll lets you decide who truly stands out as the greatest in USFL history.
These 20 USFL players were pulled from the article "The 25 best players in USFL history: No. 1—Sam Mills" See the article
Sports Fan Products
The USFL Greatest Player
Choosing the USFL greatest player of all time is never easy, as the league produced incredible talent and unforgettable performances. Each contender for the USFL best player title left a powerful legacy that helped define the league’s identity.
Kelvin Bryant’s remarkable running ability and versatility made him a fan favorite, while Bobby Hebert’s leadership and passing strength turned him into one of the top quarterbacks in USFL history. Linebacker Sam Mills stood out for his toughness and defensive brilliance, and Herschel Walker’s unmatched power and speed made him nearly unstoppable on the field.
Reggie White, known for his dominance on the defensive line, brought relentless pressure and strength, while wide receiver Anthony Carter thrilled fans with his explosive plays. Their performances not only shaped the league but also carried over into their later success in the NFL, solidifying their status among the best USFL players of all time.
Jim Kelly of the Houston Gamblers also deserves recognition as one of the USFL greatest players. His strong arm and leadership drove the league’s most dynamic offenses and paved the way for a Hall of Fame NFL career. Steve Young, from the Los Angeles Express, showcased elite athleticism and intelligence, while offensive lineman Gary Zimmerman displayed consistent excellence and earned multiple All-USFL honors.
Each of these legends brought something unique to the field. Deciding who truly deserves the title of USFL greatest player depends on personal perspective, but there’s no denying their collective impact. Their skills, dedication, and performances ensured the USFL remains remembered as a league filled with greatness.
