This poll highlights the MLB greatest Cy Young Award by comparing the most dominant pitching seasons ever recorded. Fans can review legendary Cy Young Award winners and use the Cy Young winners list to evaluate consistency, impact, and overall performance. Each vote helps decide which pitcher truly defined excellence on the mound and delivered a season worthy of the sport’s highest pitching honor.
These top 20 MLB Cy Young award winners were pulled from the article "Ranking every Cy Young Award season" See the article
Sports Fan Products
MLB Greatest Cy Young Award Poll
The MLB greatest Cy Young Award poll lets fans choose the pitcher who delivered the most dominant and memorable season in baseball history. This poll compares legendary performances across generations, using the achievements of past Cy Young Award winners and insights from the full Cy Young winners list to guide each vote.
Pitchers considered for the MLB greatest Cy Young Award earned their place through unmatched command, power, and consistency. Fans reviewing the Cy Young winners list often look at durability, strikeout ability, and overall impact to decide which season truly stands out. These comparisons help shape every vote in the poll.
Legends such as Roger Clemens, Randy Johnson, and Greg Maddux are central figures among historic Cy Young Award winners. Their dominance places them firmly in discussions about the MLB greatest Cy Young Award, and their records influence how voters judge today's pitchers. Each name on the Cy Young winners list contributes to the rich history behind this award.
This poll allows fans to evaluate pitching eras, compare elite seasons, and decide which ace deserves recognition as the true MLB greatest Cy Young Award winner. By examining both iconic Cy Young Award winners and the complete Cy Young winners list, voters can confidently select the pitcher who best represents excellence on the mound.
