The MLB greatest first basemen are celebrated for their offensive firepower, defensive skills, and consistency at the hot corner. Legends like Lou Gehrig, Albert Pujols, and Jeff Bagwell dominated the position with power hitting, clutch performances, and reliable fielding. Fans can vote in this poll to rank the best first basemen and decide who truly stands among the best first baseman of all time.
These top 20 MLB first basemen were pulled from the article "25 Greatest First Basemen in Baseball History" See the article
Sports Fan Products
The MLB Greatest First Basemen Poll
The MLB greatest first basemen are celebrated for their offensive firepower, defensive skills, and consistency at the position. Fans and experts alike can vote in this poll to determine who deserves the title of the best first basemen of all time. Legendary players like Albert Pujols, Willie McCovey, Jeff Bagwell, and others have left an enduring mark on baseball history with their hitting, fielding, and leadership.
Albert Pujols
Albert Pujols is widely regarded as one of the MLB best first basemen ever. His combination of power, consistency, and all-around offensive talent has resulted in over 600 home runs, a batting average above .300, and multiple MVP awards. Pujols also played a pivotal role in leading the St. Louis Cardinals to two World Series championships, making him a top contender in this poll.
Willie McCovey
Willie McCovey’s legendary power and run-producing ability make him a strong candidate among the MLB greatest first basemen. The San Francisco Giants star hit over 500 home runs and won the National League MVP in 1969. McCovey’s towering home runs and offensive dominance cement his place as one of the best first basemen of all time.
Jeff Bagwell
Jeff Bagwell excelled as a complete first baseman, combining power, speed, and defensive skill. A consistent offensive force for the Houston Astros, Bagwell hit over 400 home runs and won the 1994 National League MVP. His versatility and impact on both sides of the game make him a fan favorite in the MLB greatest first basemen poll.
Steve Garvey
Steve Garvey’s consistency and clutch performances helped the Los Angeles Dodgers win multiple pennants and a World Series. Known for his contact hitting and leadership, Garvey earned the 1974 National League MVP and is remembered as one of the best first basemen in MLB history.
Orlando Cepeda
Nicknamed "Baby Bull," Orlando Cepeda was a dominant offensive threat and the 1967 National League MVP. With over 350 home runs in his career, Cepeda’s contributions to the game highlight his place among the MLB greatest first basemen.
Don Mattingly
Don Mattingly, "Donnie Baseball," showcased a smooth swing, excellent defense, and leadership during his time with the New York Yankees. Winner of the 1985 American League MVP, Mattingly remains one of the most beloved figures and a strong contender in the MLB best first basemen poll.
Deciding the MLB greatest first basemen is subjective and depends on personal preferences. Each of these players has left a lasting legacy, and this poll gives fans the chance to vote for who they believe is the best first baseman of all time.
