The MLB greatest shortstops are known for elite defense, quick instincts, and strong leadership. Fans often debate the MLB best shortstop and the best shortstop in MLB, as each player brings exceptional athleticism and game awareness. This poll lets you decide which legendary shortstop deserves the top ranking.
These top 20 MLB shortstops were pulled from the article "50 Greatest Shortstops in Baseball History" See the article
Sports Fan Products
The MLB Greatest Shortstops Poll
The MLB greatest shortstops are known for their elite defense, quick reactions, and smart decision-making. Fans often debate the MLB best shortstop and the best shortstop in MLB, as the position has produced some of the most complete players in baseball. These shortstops shaped their teams through consistency, leadership, and high-level performance.
Cal Ripken Jr., Derek Jeter, and Honus Wagner are among the legends who defined the role. They blended strong fielding, reliable hitting, and unmatched durability. Their ability to handle pressure and guide infield defense made them vital to long-term success. As a result, each of these stars played a major part in raising the standard for future shortstops.
Their impact goes beyond statistics. They influenced how teams value athleticism, communication, and leadership at the position. Because of their contributions, the shortstop role evolved into one of the most demanding and respected positions in MLB. This poll gives fans a chance to rank the all-time greats and decide who truly stands as the greatest at shortstop.
