The MLS greatest player poll celebrates the stars who defined soccer in North America. Fans can vote for the MLS best player and decide who truly deserves the title of the best player in MLS history. From record-setting goal scorers to creative midfielders and legendary defenders, this poll brings every era together to honor the league’s all-time greats.
These 20 MLS players were pulled from the article "Football Greats: Ranking the Top 25 MLS Players of All-Time" See the article
Sports Fan Products
MLS Greatest Player Poll
Debating the MLS greatest player of all time always sparks passion among fans. Each era of Major League Soccer has produced stars who defined the league in their own way. Choosing the MLS best player or the best player in MLS history isn’t easy. Every contender brought unique skills, achievements, and unforgettable moments to the sport.
Jaime Moreno remains one of the most influential figures in MLS history. As a forward for D.C. United, he helped the team capture four MLS Cups. Known for his control, vision, and finishing touch, Moreno’s leadership and creativity earned him lasting respect. Many fans still view him as a strong candidate for the title of MLS greatest player.
Eddie Pope set the standard for elite defending in Major League Soccer. Calm, reliable, and intelligent on the field, Pope was a cornerstone of D.C. United’s championship teams. His positioning, timing, and leadership earned him countless honors. His consistency makes him one of the best players in MLS history, admired for both talent and character.
Landon Donovan is often called the face of American soccer. With six MLS Cups and multiple MVP awards, he dominated the league for years. Donovan’s speed, creativity, and ability to score in big moments made him one of the MLS best players ever. His impact went beyond the field, inspiring an entire generation of U.S. soccer fans.
Brian McBride left his mark as one of the league’s most respected strikers. Playing for the Columbus Crew and Chicago Fire, he combined strength, aerial dominance, and precise finishing. McBride’s leadership and professionalism helped elevate the standard of play across the league. His contributions to both MLS and U.S. soccer make him a serious contender for MLS greatest player.
Marco Etcheverry, famously known as “El Diablo,” dazzled audiences with his flair and creativity. As D.C. United’s playmaker, he guided his team to several MLS titles. Etcheverry’s passing and vision made him one of the most technically gifted stars of his era. His influence ensures his place among the best players in MLS history.
Tony Meola was a goalkeeper who set new standards for excellence in the league’s early years. His reflexes, communication, and leadership made him a dominant figure between the posts. Meola’s awards and performances confirmed his reputation as one of the MLS best players, especially in the goalkeeping position.
Ultimately, naming the MLS greatest player comes down to personal choice. Whether it’s Donovan’s leadership, Moreno’s brilliance, or Meola’s heroics, each of these legends left a lasting mark. They shaped the league’s identity and continue to inspire players who dream of becoming the next best player in MLS history.
