The MLS Greatest Scorer Poll highlights the strikers who defined scoring excellence in Major League Soccer. This poll features every MLS leading goal scorer and celebrates each MLS top scorer who delivered consistent goals, clutch performances, and unforgettable moments. Fans can vote to decide which scorer stands above the rest and deserves the title of the greatest in MLS history.
These 20 MLS scorers were pulled from the article " The most successful goal scorers: Major League Soccer " See the article
Sports Fan Products
The MLS Greatest Scorer Poll
The MLS greatest scorer debate continues as fans compare legends who shaped the league with their consistency and finishing ability. This poll highlights every major MLS leading goal scorer and honors each MLS top scorer who left a significant mark on the league. With so many elite forwards across different eras, determining the greatest requires looking closely at their achievements, influence, and impact on Major League Soccer.
Jason Kreis
Jason Kreis stands out as one of the most reliable goal scorers in MLS history. Known for his intelligence and precision in the box, he became the first player to reach 100 goals and cemented his place among the MLS greatest scorer candidates. His consistency made him a frequent mention whenever fans discuss the MLS leading goal scorer title.
Josh Wolff
Josh Wolff brought speed and creativity that made him a constant threat. While he may not top the MLS top scorer list, his contributions and playmaking helped elevate every attack he led. His influence keeps him relevant in conversations about the most impactful scorers to play in MLS.
Landon Donovan
Landon Donovan remains one of the most iconic names in league history. Donovan led the league in goals for years, becoming a true MLS leading goal scorer with unmatched consistency. His ability to combine playmaking with scoring excellence puts him firmly in the running for the MLS greatest scorer title and ensures his legacy remains central to MLS history.
Brian McBride
Brian McBride added strength and aerial power to the league’s scoring ranks. His ability to dominate physically and finish under pressure earned him a respected place among the MLS top scorer contenders. McBride’s leadership and impact also helped shape the growth of American soccer during its early MLS years.
Dom Dwyer
Dom Dwyer showcased relentless effort and finishing ability. His tenacity made him a standout attacker, and while he may not lead the MLS leading goal scorer charts, his influence on his teams’ successes keeps him firmly in the conversation.
Robbie Keane
Robbie Keane brought world-class quality to MLS and quickly became one of the most lethal scorers in league history. His technique, movement, and finishing made him a top MLS greatest scorer candidate. Keane’s consistent goal production and leadership helped the LA Galaxy dominate during his tenure.
Choosing the MLS greatest scorer comes down to personal preference, era, and the style of play fans value most. Each MLS top scorer mentioned contributed to the league in unique ways—through records, longevity, or memorable performances. Their legacies continue to shape how fans view scoring excellence in MLS, making every vote in this poll an important part of the ongoing discussion.
