Choosing the premier league greatest goalie is never easy, especially with so many iconic names competing for the top spot. Each legendary Premier League goalie brought unique skills, big-match performances, and unforgettable moments to the league. Fans still debate who should be considered the best goalkeeper all time, and this poll gives you the chance to decide which star truly deserves that title.
These 20 Premier League goalies were pulled from the article "The Premier League's greatest ever goalkeepers ranked into tiers" See the article
Sports Fan Products
The Premier League Greatest Goalie Poll
Determining the Premier League greatest goalie is not easy, especially with so many iconic names shaping the league. Each Premier League goalie brought unique strengths, defining moments and qualities that fans still admire. Because this poll focuses on legends often compared to the best goalkeeper all time, every viewpoint matters when choosing the top contender.
Peter Schmeichel remains a leading candidate for the Premier League greatest goalie thanks to his commanding presence and unmatched influence at Manchester United. His shot-stopping ability, leadership and consistency helped define what fans expect from the best goalkeeper all time, placing him near the top of nearly every Premier League goalie ranking.
David Seaman also earned his place among the elite. His reliability and acrobatic saves guided Arsenal through multiple title-winning seasons. His calm style and control in big moments strengthened his case for anyone voting for the Premier League greatest goalie in this poll.
David de Gea added a modern edge to the discussion. His lightning-quick reflexes, athletic stops and long period of consistency kept him in conversations not only as a top Premier League goalie but as one of the best goalkeeper all time candidates based on peak performance.
Joe Hart’s impact at Manchester City cannot be overlooked. His leadership and shot-stopping record across City’s early Premier League title runs help many fans view him as a legitimate option for the Premier League greatest goalie title. His best years were filled with crucial saves that shaped seasons.
Tim Howard also produced unforgettable moments in goal. His athletic ability and historic performances for Everton created a strong case for recognition. Although he is not always listed as the best goalkeeper all time, he remains a respected and important Premier League goalie in league history.
Ederson brought a completely different style, redefining modern goalkeeping with his distribution, sweeper-keeper movement and consistency at Manchester City. His unique skill set keeps his name in discussions about the Premier League greatest goalie, especially for fans who value modern tactical impact.
Choosing the Premier League greatest goalie ultimately depends on personal preference. Still, each of these legends shaped the league in a meaningful way. Their records, influence and unforgettable moments ensure they stay part of every debate about the best goalkeeper all time and the most exceptional Premier League goalie ever to take the field.
